Lakes, Creeks, and Hidden Gems: Fishing Near Payson

Explore the hidden fishing gems near Payson, from tranquil lakes to scenic trails, perfect for a peaceful day outdoors.

Published October 29, 2026

Living in Payson is a daily adventure, where the mornings greet you with crisp air and the scent of pine filling your lungs. The beauty of Rim Country surrounds you, with the light dancing on the mountains as the sun rises, and community life thrives among the stunning scenery. If fishing is your passion or you're simply looking for a peaceful day by the water, there are some hidden gems nearby that will fulfill that craving.

Horton Creek Trailhead

Just a short drive from downtown Payson, Horton Creek Trailhead is a favorite among locals. Visitors rave about the well-maintained trails that weave through beautiful scenery, offering plenty of shade and stunning creek crossings. It’s an excellent spot for both hiking and fishing, with opportunities to filter fresh water along the way. Many mention the peaceful ambiance, making it ideal for a day spent in nature, whether you're casting a line or simply enjoying the tranquility.

Green Valley Park

Only a stone’s throw from the heart of Payson, Green Valley Park is one of those spots where the community gathers. The tranquil lake here is perfect for a leisurely afternoon, and the paths around it make for easy walking or a delightful picnic. People often comment on the friendly atmosphere, as neighbors come to fish or stroll through the park, making it a vibrant part of daily life. The large grassy areas and beautiful views of the mountains only add to the charm.

Water Wheel Falls Hiking Trail

A bit of a drive, but well worth it, Water Wheel Falls offers a short yet scenic hike along the river. Locals love the easy access to fishing right by the falls, and the views are breathtaking. Families flock here to enjoy the numerous spots for picnicking and splashing around in the water. Many visitors remark on the beauty of the area, with the trail providing both a moderate challenge and stunning scenery that makes for memorable days outdoors.

Christopher Creek Campground

For those looking to immerse themselves in nature, Christopher Creek Campground is a fantastic option. Just a short drive from Payson, this campground provides large, spacious sites nestled among tall pines. Visitors often highlight the serene feel of the campground, with nearby water access that’s perfect for fishing. The camaraderie among campers makes it a great spot for families and friends to gather, enjoying the peaceful sounds of nature.

Fossil Creek Dam (aka The Toilet Bowl)

A little further out, Fossil Creek Dam is a popular hiking destination known for its stunning scenery and incredible waterfall. Hikers often enjoy the well-preserved paths that lead to breathtaking views, and fishing here is a delightful bonus. Comments from visitors frequently mention the beauty of the area and the refreshing escape it provides. The hike is manageable, making it a perfect getaway for those seeking adventure combined with the tranquility of nature.

See Canyon Trailhead

Lastly, See Canyon Trailhead is another favorite among local hikers. Known for its incredible views and well-marked trails, many visitors love the journey it offers. Along the way, you might discover flowing water and lush scenery to enjoy while fishing or just taking a break. The beauty of this trail is often praised, with the peaceful environment making it a perfect spot to reconnect with nature.

Written by Brian Inman, REALTOR® — Mountain Bear Homes, Payson, Arizona. Call (623) 512-9763 or email brian@mountainbearhomes.com.

https://mountainbearhomes.com/blog-posts/lakes-creeks-and-hidden-gems-fishing-near-payson/