Price Range Guide

Payson AZ Homes $300K–$500K

The most active price range in Rim Country real estate.

The $300,000–$500,000 price range is the heart of the Payson real estate market. It represents the broadest pool of both buyers and available homes, and it's where the Rim Country offers some of its best value — especially compared to Phoenix, where $400K doesn't go nearly as far.

Search Current Listings

Updated in real time with the latest MLS listings filtered to this price range.

View Homes $300K–$500K

What Does Your Budget Get You?

~$300K–$350K

Smaller homes (1,000–1,400 sq ft), older builds, possibly needing some updating. Good starter homes or investment properties in Star Valley or outer Payson areas.

~$350K–$425K

The sweet spot. 3-bedroom, 2-bath homes in solid condition. Often 1,200–1,800 sq ft with a garage, updated kitchens, and decent lots. Most move-in ready.

~$425K–$500K

Better finishes, larger lots, newer builds, or well-updated older homes. You'll start to see some mountain views, covered patios, and more space (1,600–2,200 sq ft).

Tips for Buyers in This Range

Get pre-approved first — homes in the $350K–$450K range move fast. You need a pre-approval letter ready before scheduling showings.
Be flexible on area — Star Valley typically offers more home for the money than central Payson at the same price.
Budget for a well inspection if applicable — some properties use private wells. Testing is cheap; surprises are not.
Know your must-haves — in a tight inventory market, the "perfect" home rarely appears. Prioritize before you start.

Let's Find the Right Home

Brian works with buyers at every price point. He'll tell you what's a fair deal, what's overpriced, and what hidden gems are worth a second look.

Call Brian — (623) 512-9763